The Fourth Turning presents a cyclical view of history, proposing that society moves through four "turnings" every 80-100 years. Many readers find the theory compelling and eerily prescient, noting accurate predictions about generational traits and societal crises. Critics argue the book oversimplifies history, relies on selective evidence, and makes vague predictions. Some appreciate its fresh perspective on historical patterns, while others dismiss it as pseudoscience. The book's influence on political figures and its predictions about an impending crisis have sparked both intrigue and concern among readers.
The Saeculum: History's Recurring Cycle of Four Turnings
Generational Archetypes: Prophet, Nomad, Hero, and Artist
The First Turning: High - An Era of Stability and Growth
The Second Turning: Awakening - A Time of Spiritual Upheaval
The Third Turning: Unraveling - A Period of Individualism and Weakening Institutions
The Fourth Turning: Crisis - A Time of Secular Upheaval and Renewal
The Millennial Saeculum: America's Current Cycle and Future Crisis
The Role of Generations in Shaping Historical Cycles
Preparing for the Fourth Turning: Individual and Societal Strategies
"History creates generations, and generations create history."
The saeculum concept. The saeculum is a natural cycle of human history, roughly the length of a long human life, typically lasting 80-100 years. This cycle consists of four distinct phases, called "turnings," each lasting about 20-25 years:
First Turning: High
Second Turning: Awakening
Third Turning: Unraveling
Fourth Turning: Crisis
Historical patterns. This cyclical pattern has been observed throughout Anglo-American history, with each saeculum marked by recurring themes and social moods. The authors argue that understanding these cycles can provide insights into future societal trends and challenges.
"Each generation has what all of history has not: a beginning, an end, and a finite path in between."
Four archetypes. The authors identify four generational archetypes that play crucial roles in shaping the turnings:
Prophet: Idealistic, principled, and moralistic (e.g., Baby Boomers)
Nomad: Pragmatic, survivalist, and alienated (e.g., Generation X)
Hero: Civic-minded, confident, and team-oriented (e.g., G.I. Generation)
Artist: Adaptive, sensitive, and compromising (e.g., Silent Generation)
Generational cycles. These archetypes appear in a fixed sequence, with each generation shaped by the social environment of its childhood and young adulthood. The interplay between these archetypes and their life stages drives the progression of the saeculum.
"A First Turning is a High—an upbeat era of strengthening institutions and weakening individualism, when a new civic order implants and the old values regime decays."
Characteristics of a High. The First Turning is characterized by:
Strong institutions and social cohesion
Economic prosperity and technological advancement
Conformity and collective optimism
Weakening of individualism
Historical examples. Notable First Turnings in American history include the post-World War II era (1946-1964) and the Era of Good Feelings following the War of 1812 (1815-1829). These periods were marked by economic growth, social stability, and a sense of national purpose.
"An Awakening arrives with a dramatic challenge against the High's assumptions about benevolent reason and congenial institutions."
Characteristics of an Awakening. The Second Turning features:
Spiritual and cultural revolutions
Questioning of established institutions and values
Focus on personal authenticity and self-expression
Generational conflict between older and younger cohorts
Historical examples. Significant Awakenings include the Transcendental Awakening (1822-1844) and the Consciousness Revolution (1964-1984). These eras saw the rise of new spiritual movements, countercultures, and challenges to traditional social norms.
"An Unraveling begins as a society-wide embrace of the liberating cultural forces set loose by the Awakening."
Characteristics of an Unraveling. The Third Turning is marked by:
Weakening of institutions and social trust
Rising individualism and cultural fragmentation
Economic uncertainty and widening wealth gaps
Cynicism towards leadership and public life
Current Unraveling. The authors argue that America entered its most recent Unraveling in the 1980s, characterized by culture wars, political gridlock, and eroding faith in public institutions. This period is expected to last until the early 2020s.
"The risk of catastrophe will be very high. The nation could erupt into insurrection or civil violence, crack up geographically, or succumb to authoritarian rule."
Characteristics of a Crisis. The Fourth Turning involves:
Major societal upheaval and transformation
Collective focus on solving existential threats
Realignment of power structures and institutions
Potential for both great achievements and catastrophic outcomes
Historical crises. Previous Fourth Turnings include the American Revolution, the Civil War, and the Great Depression/World War II. These periods reshaped American society and institutions in fundamental ways.
"Sometime around the year 2005, perhaps a few years before or after, America will enter the Fourth Turning."
Current saeculum timeline. The authors outline the current Millennial Saeculum:
First Turning (High): 1946-1964
Second Turning (Awakening): 1964-1984
Third Turning (Unraveling): 1984-2005?
Fourth Turning (Crisis): 2005?-2025?
Potential catalysts. The authors suggest various scenarios that could trigger the next Crisis, including:
Economic distress or collapse
Technological disruptions
Ecological disasters
Political upheaval or constitutional crisis
Major terrorist attacks or international conflicts
"Generations are among the most powerful forces in history."
Generational dynamics. The interplay between generations drives the saecular cycle:
Prophet generation (Boomers) leads spiritual awakenings in young adulthood and steers the Crisis in elderhood
Nomad generation (Gen X) provides pragmatic leadership during the Crisis
Hero generation (Millennials) comes of age during the Crisis and builds the new order afterward
Artist generation (Silent) adapts and mediates between the other archetypes
Generational constellations. The alignment of generations in different life stages creates unique social dynamics during each turning, influencing how society responds to challenges and opportunities.
"The Fourth Turning will be a time of glory or ruin."
Individual preparation. The authors suggest ways to prepare for the coming Crisis:
Develop practical skills and resilience
Build strong community ties and social networks
Cultivate a sense of civic responsibility
Understand historical patterns to anticipate challenges
Societal strategies. To navigate the Fourth Turning successfully, society should:
Strengthen core institutions and infrastructure
Foster intergenerational cooperation and understanding
Develop flexible and adaptive governance structures
Cultivate a shared sense of national purpose and values
Potential outcomes. The authors emphasize that the result of the Crisis is not predetermined. Society's choices during this period will shape the new order that emerges, with the potential for either renewal and progress or decline and fragmentation.